Like Old Time Hockey!
March 17th, 2008 by Kevin
I hate to correct the hockey guru of the MOB, but Chad\’s bitching commenting about the extra point that magically appears if two NHL teams go into overtime, while not incorrect, is missing a bit of historical context. With that historical context the rather asinine scoring setup appears slightly less ridiculous.
While I agree the automagical addition of an extra point just because the teams were too evenly-matched/incompetent/hesitant/trap-happy/french/etc is rather bizarre but it did have an actual reason for it at one point.
Basically that teams that went into overtime tied often stayed in overtime. The NHL in it\’s infinite possibly existant wisdom decided the reason that teams were scoring is because they were fearful of granting a two points to their opponent and nothing for themselves so they sat back on defense. So the idea being that if both teams have nothing to lose, in that they are both guaranteed a point, but only another point to gain, they\’ll try harder in overtime!
Of course, what was perfectly sound reasoning then was revealed to be much less so in real life. In reality, in a tight playoff race, that extra point for your opponent is still not a good thing to grant so in as much as that had any relation to how teams played the motivation to sit back on defense was still there. Plus the reasons why scoring has been extremely low is hardly limited to strategic point-mongering. Rather it\’s likely a complex combination of a massive number of reasons, all of which are currently archived in a huge complex of warehouses occasionally mistaken as Detroit.
Having not solved the problem they then changed the rules by adding a shootout, which destroyed the entire point for having a motivating factor to settle a tied game since there are no longer tie games.
So now we are left with the logical result. A point system that makes no sense, was ineffective even when it sorta did and low scoring which results in lots of tie games. That sound you heard was Bobby Orr farting.
Email This Post
| Print This Post
Posted in All Things Hockey | 1 Comment »