If you listen to the Democrats, Iraq is quite simply a bottomless hellhole without a chance of success. They used to cite the 18 benchmarks are proof that Iraq was a failed experiment and we should pull out. Meanwhile, as I pointed out a year ago, if you apply equivalent benchmarks towards our government, we score significantly less than Iraq does. Well recently the surge, despite claims by Democrats everywhere, has had enough of an impact that the Iraqi government has made a number of significant improvements and met quite a few of the remaining benchmarks.
So let’s revisit the issue shall we? Let’s see how the Iraqis have improved…and if our government has improved it’s score at all.
Goal: Ensuring political groups do not undermine security forces
Last year : Iraq failed, and so did we.
Today : It’s still a work in progress for Iraq. And with Democrats constantly claiming the surge is failed and doing everything to undermine support for our troops both domestically and abroad, it’s fairly safe to say it’s a work in progress for us too.
Goal: Reconciliation with former Baathists
Last year : Iraq failed, as did we.
Today : Actually the combination of the new election laws and the amnesty moves this into the plus category for Iraq. Our progress has been considerably less admirable. The hatred between Republicans and Democrats is still as strong as ever. If you doubt that, just read the vicious bile directed towards Nancy Reagan upon news that she fell and potentially broke a hip.
Goal: Reducing the level of sectarian violence and eliminating militia control of local security
Last year : We passed, Iraq failed
Today : Well BushCo’s brownshirt have yet to make their first appearance and time is running out. Meanwhile, in Iraq I’m tempted to be optimistic here but I’ll refrain. It’s still largely a work in progress. Granted violence in Baghdad is down 80% and the militia’s are losing control. However, if the Mahdi Army had not renewed their cease fire recently things could have been significantly different lately. So this is a VERY tentative fail….in reality it’s a pass, but only because cooler heads are prevailing for now. Only when cooler heads are no longer required could I really count this is a true Pass.
Goal: Provide Iraqi commanders with authority to go after insurgents and militia, whether Sunni or Shia, without political intervention
Last year : We failed, Iraq failed
Today : With the failure to renew FISA we definitely fail. And part of the reason the Mahdi cease fire was in question, was because government forces have been going after Shia militia members. At this point it’s likely that the commanders don’t receive any more interference than they might in most other areas of the world. I’ll give them a pass here.
Goal: Increasing the number of Iraqi security forces units capable of operating independently
Last year : We failed, and so did the Iraqis
Today : Yeah, we still fail (I’m noticing a trend here), for the same reasons we failed last year. Iraqi on the other hand has increased their forces considerably. Most of the country has been handed over to Iraqi forces and elsewhere Iraqi forces are operating with mostly minimal American assistance. We’re even starting to draw down our number of forces. I’ll give them a pass here.
Goal: Disarming militias
Last year : We failed, as did Iraq
Today : Homeland Security Department still a clusterfuck wrapped in red tape, big fail for us. Militias in Iraq have been reduced in effectiveness but they haven’t been disarmed, most notably the Mahdi army. Fair for both.
Goal: Raising Iraqi brigades to support operations in Baghdad
Last year : Iraq passed, we failed.
Today : Same results. In fact Iraq has made further progress, we have….well we’ve talked about it alot.
Goal: Establishing joint US-Iraq security stations in neighbourhoods across Baghdad
Last year : Iraq passed, we failed
Today : Same results. How’s that fence coming?? Latest excuse is….[shakes magic 8-Ball]….environmentalists.
Goal: Amnesty for insurgents
Last year : Iraq failed, so did we
Today : Iraq has passed an amnesty, so they come out with a big pass here. I’m tempted to give us a fail since there has been rumbling of an amnesty for us, but it hasn’t come to fruition so I’ll give us both a pass.
Goal: Election reform
Last year : We both failed
Today : Iraq passed new election reform laws. We have done absolutely nothing….and Florida has proven they still can’t get this whole election thing right.
Goal: Political support for Baghdad security plan
Last year : Iraq passed, we failed
Today : Iraq still passes. Meanwhile, San Fransisco and Toledo have kicked out the Marines….I repeat….kicked out the Marines. I award us no points and may God have mercy on Medea Benjamin’s soul.
Goal: To deny Baghdad as a safe haven for al-Qaida and insurgents regardless of religion
Last year : Iraq passed, we failed
Today : Same results. We still have sanctuary cities aplenty.
Goal: Ensuring that the Iraqi security forces are providing even-handed enforcement of the law
Last year : We passed, Iraq failed
Today : Same results. So far sanity has prevailed here at home. Over in Iraq, this is a pretty subjective benchmark so I’ll lean towards the side of caution and give Iraq a fail.
Goal: Fairly allocating and spending $10 billion in Iraqi revenues for reconstruction
Last year : Iraq passed, we failed
Today : Same results. Iraq is improving even more. We still have spending issues. Earmarks still out of control. Entitlements are ready to bankrupt us. Oh joy!
Goal: Introducing laws that would allow autonomous regions
Last year : Iraq passed, we failed.
Today : Same results. Iraq has actually made further progress with their elections reform. Meanwhile, Congress continues to do absolutely nothing, leaving states to figure out things for themselves.
Goal: Constitutional review and reform
Last year : Iraq passed, we failed
Today : Same results for the same reasons.
Goal: Protect minority political rights in the Iraqi legislature
Last year : We both passed
Today : Same results for the same reason.
Goal: Passing an oil law
Last year : Both failed
Today : Well we still haven’t drilled, built a refinery or a nuclear plant. So that’s a big F for us. Iraq….well, they haven’t officially passed an oil law. However, they have passed a national budget evenly distributed and most of that money came from oil sales. So one could claim they accomplished this benchmark in spirit, but I’ll still hold out for the fine print and give this a tentative fail.
Ok so granted, I’m not comparing apples to apples, but each country faces it’s own issues. Nevertheless, Iraq comes out with a 13, and we come across with a 4. Both countries improved, from our past scores of 8 and 3 respectively. Perhaps this is the reason we’re hearing alot less about the failure of the surge from Reid and Pelosi. Could it be that their failure to accomplish anything of substance is glaringly obvious, while the so called failed surge has no basis in reality?