Well release of the timeline of our plans in Iraq hit the news recently and appear to have made a splash amongst an already war-weary public. And did it surprise anyone to see that it was the New York Times that released the contents of the secret plan?? Of course Cindy Sheehan got arrested recently for yet another anti-war protest. So this topic of war isn\’t going away.
What I find curious is that part of this talk is about the lack of progress of the Iraqi government. Sure they\’ve had their failings, and they\’ve been less than stellar so far but how bad are they doing really?? I mean compared to say….a country with 200+ years of experience at this, how are they doing.
Let\’s take a look at those 18 benchmarks we keep hearing about….and let\’s see how WE are doing against similar benchmarks. The Iraqis got eight out of eighteen….
Goal: Ensuring political groups do not undermine security forces
Unsatisfactory: The effort to make sure that the political authorities are not undermining the security forces or making false accusations is not working properly. The effect is to deny the security forces the services of qualified officers.
You mean like Rep Murtha making false accusations against US soldiers?? Or the Pentagon declaring the Clinton\’s political rhetoric was helping the enemy?? Or Democrats trying their best to give our enemies the best chance at survival? You mean liberals constantly second guessing our troops and hamstringing them with impossible rules and regulations?? You mean like that???
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Reconciliation with former Baathists
Unsatisfactory: Iraqi leaders have been struggling to find a way to accommodate former Baath party members in the political mainstream, and reverse what is now acknowledged as excessive zeal in excluding people with ties to the former Saddam regime.
Basically this boils down to bi-partisanship….and really I can\’t even come up with plausible satire here. Anyone want to even try to claim there is ANY level of bi-partisanship in Washington??
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Reducing the level of sectarian violence and eliminating militia control of local security
Unsatisfactory: Militias are still dominant force in parts of Baghdad, Basra and many provinces.
Well despite liberals claims of BushCo\’s brown shirts and Republican Nazis I think we\’re doing pretty good here. I haven\’t noticed any new government run political prisoner camps opening up lately.
Our grade : PASSED
Goal: Provide Iraqi commanders with authority to go after insurgents and militia, whether Sunni or Shia, without political intervention
Unsatisfactory: The Iraqi commanders have been given the authority but there is continuing political interference along sectarian lines. The Shia-dominated government is reluctant to tackle Shia militia.
Hell our security forces can\’t even go after terrorists without some liberal bitching.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Increasing the number of Iraqi security forces units capable of operating independently
Unsatisfactory: Iraqi army performing better than police but both need presence of US and other coalition forces.
Yeah, we were supposed to increase the size of one of our security forces too, namely the Border Patrol. We haven\’t. And we\’ve even taking to imprisoning them when they do their job.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Disarming militias
Too soon to judge: The conditions are not yet on the ground to bring in legislation that would set out a process for disarming militias, and ensuring a single Iraqi security force accountable only to the Iraqi government.
A single security force huh?? I think that\’s what our Homeland Security Department was intended to do, unite all our security forces under a single banner. So how did that work out….well it\’s chief\’s best efforts have resulted in a \”gut feeling\”.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Raising Iraqi brigades to support operations in Baghdad
Satisfactory: Although the Iraqi government struggled initially to deploy three additional full brigades in support of the surge in Baghdad, it managed to pull in enough forces from other divisions by last month.
Well we\’ve been struggling to hire enough border patrol guards to man the border, so we managed to re-assign some of them to guard presidential candidates, instead of the border. Priorities you know.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Establishing joint US-Iraq security stations in neighbourhoods across Baghdad
Satisfactory: Thirty-six such stations have been fully-established and 32 partially-established.
Eight hundred miles of fence to be built, how much have we built?? Eleven. Oh and a couple years ago we put some fencing on the wrong side of the border so we have to rebuild that.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Amnesty for insurgents
Too soon to judge: There has been almost no movement towards an amnesty law for insurgents. However, the White House says the time is not ripe because of ongoing violence.
Well we tried to pass amnesty for illegal immigrants. Fortunately that failed….TWICE. But they are still trying to bring back parts.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Election reform
Usatisfactory: The White House divides this benchmark into four parts. It gives a satisfactory grade to the Iraqi government for establishing a commission to oversee general elections. However, it fails the Iraqi authorities for failing to draft a provincial election law, or establish provincial council authorities. The Iraqi government has also failed to set a date for provincial elections.
Election reform….yeah, we could use that too!!
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Political support for Baghdad security plan
Satisfactory: The Iraqi government has set up political, economic, and media committees to try to reinforce security operations in Baghdad
Political support for a secure Iraq?? Yeah, right, not with the Code Pinkos and the KosKids climbing all over each other to be the first to surrender to Al Qaeda. And the Democrats can\’t do anything but follow the lead of the fever swamp.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: To deny Baghdad as a safe haven for al-Qaida and insurgents regardless of religion
Satisfactory: Enough progress has been made to allow US and Iraqi forces to continue clearing and securing areas in and around Baghdad.
Would I be beating a dead horse too much here if I made a reference to sanctuary cities for illegals??? Yeah….okay, you fill in the blanks here.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Ensuring that the Iraqi security forces are providing even-handed enforcement of the law
Unsatisfactory: Sunnis continue to believe that the Shia-dominated police force and army is biased against them. The presence of US and other coalition forces has had a positive effect on ensuring a more even-handed approach.
Well, liberals continue to believe that the liberal-dominated media is biased towards liberals, so they introduce the Fairness Doctrine to introduce even more liberal filth. It\’s failure had a positive effect on media and the sanity of everyone.
Our grade : PASSED
Goal: Fairly allocating and spending $10 billion in Iraqi revenues for reconstruction
Satisfactory: Need to speed up spending in the coming months.
Somehow I think our problem is not speeding up spending but slowing it down.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Introducing laws that would allow autonomous regions
Satisfactory: The Iraqi parliament has passed legislation to allow semi-autonomous regions such as in Kurdistan. However, there is no chance of implementation until after provincial elections are held.
Well since the US Congress has pretty much done nothing this term, they\’ve effectively made every state an autonomous region. Although I\’m not sure that was the spirit of this benchmark.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Constitutional review and reform
Satisfactory: A constitutional review committee was formed in November last year to try to resolve conflicts over such issues as the division of power between the centre and the regions, and the status of Kirkuk. It put forward preliminary recommendations last May, and received an extension to deal with the more contentious issues
Ok let\’s save the review and reform….how about we just concentrate on getting the Feds to follow the Constitution first. THEN we can start working on this review/reform thing.
Our grade : FAILED
Goal: Protect minority political rights in the Iraqi legislature
Satisfactory: Minority political parties participate fully, as do women.
Ron Paul and Dennis Kucinich, I rest my case.
Our grade : PASSED
Goal: Passing an oil law
Unsatisfactory: Producing legislation that would allow for the fair distribution of Iraq\’s oil resources among Shias, Sunnis and Kurds is seen as crucial for future stability. However, negotiations remain deadlocked by a Sunni party boycott.
Still not drilling domestic oil, still no new refineries, still no new nuclear plants, instead we\’re just concentrating on burning our food supply.
Our grade : FAILED
So the Iraqis got eight out of eighteen, how did we do??? Well we got three out of eighteen.
Hmmm, me thinks someone scored slightly better.