Three things are certain: Death, taxes, and lost data. Guess which has occurred...

« Humor : The Hangover | Home | Home Defense Firepower »

Diversity vs REAL Diversity

March 31st, 2005 by Kevin

Doug has a post up regarding what some bloggers apparently feeling diversity is. Apparently you are only “different” if:

1. They can’t be male if they are white;
2. You must have five women and five men;
3. You must have at least three non-Americans.

*sigh*

This reminds me of my companys approach to diversity. Only look at the skin color, the sex…or anything else we can check off in a column. We’re diverse!! Because this spreadsheet says so!!!!

Wrong. For all you know those minorities were all raised in the same type of environment that all your whites were raised in. For all you know those females have had a more priveleged upbringing than your males.

It’s a common belief though.

But I did have a ray of hope awhile back. I’m not going to name names, but someone once expressed to me their exasperation with this policy and their view of what diversity SHOULD be.

They way we communicate. They way we think. They way we react to situations. They way we process information. The world views we have. For example, the Meyers-Briggs personality test was fronted as a much better alternative. If you know what type of personality someone has you are much more able to work with them. You know how they approach problems and you are better able to work together even though you view the world through different eyes.

Now you can nitpick all you want about the teachings of Carl Jung (upon whose teachings Meyers-Briggs is based on) all you want. And I’m not necessarily a big fan of his teachings either. But the point is this sounded like a hell of a more sensible approach than simply looking at someone’s skin color and making assumptions about them.

UPDATE: For the record, I have repeatedly tested as an ESTJ in the Meyers-Briggs test. Good descriptions of what that means are here, here and here. And even though I’m skeptical of the test, I have to agree that these descriptions are fairly accurate of me.

Email This Post Email This Post | Print This Post Print This Post
Posted in General Commentary |

4 Responses

  1. Harvey Says:

    I usually test ASOB on personality tests :-)

  2. Flash Says:

    Actually, ASOB isn’t all the much different then ESTJ. I also test in the ESTJ catagory, and liken it to Stubborn SOB *laughing*

    Flash

  3. Night Writer Says:

    My company has a similar statement along the ines of having “a high performance culture that honors diversity.” I was on a large group conference call and this statement came up. I pointed out that if you combine “performance” with “diversity” you get “perversity.”

    It got very, very quiet for some time on the call. I thought my termination orders were being typed. Gradually people started drifting back onto the call - apparently there had been a near simultaneous pounding of “mute” buttons to cover politically incorrect snorting. Anyway, I’m still here, perservering.

  4. Kevin Says:

    When I attended the training course to prepare me for going to colleges to recruit new grads, I thought I was going to burst.

    Listening to the HR person try to explain why we should give preference to minorities without actually saying exactly that was painful. Then one of my co-workers piped up with “Heh, I don’t care what they look like. I just care how they perform.” You could see the HR person almost cry as she tried to convert us.

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.